Available in Russian
Author: Alexander Solntsev
DOI: 10.21128/2226-2059-2025-1-56-69
Keywords: climate change; environmental pollution; toxic waste; environmental human rights
The case in question concerns systematic and long-term environmental pollution in the Campania region of Italy, known as “Terra dei Fuochi” (“Land of Fires”), where illegal dumping and burning of hazardous waste has taken place for decades, leading to serious health consequences for the local population. The judgment in Cannavacciuolo and Others v. Italy, delivered by the European Court of Human Rights on 30 January 2025, represents an important precedent for the development of environmental human rights. It is the first judgment linking a violation of the right to life to long-term exposure to pollutants emitted into the environment. The decisive element for the applicability of the right to life was the change in the Court’s approach to the requirement of causation that gives rise to a violation of Article 2. Moreover, this is the Court’s first pilot-judgment procedure in an environmental case, which provides for the adoption by Italy of a whole range of measures to improve the state of the environment in Campania. The judgment in Cannavacciuolo and Others v. Italy should therefore be seen as a turning point for environmental justice.
About the author: Alexander Solntsev – Candidate of Sciences (Ph.D.) in Law, Associate Professor, Deputy Head of the Department of International Law in Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia named after Patrice Lumumba, Moscow, Russia.
Citation: Solntsev A. (2025) Pravo na zhizn': ekotest nakonets proyden: Kommentariy k Postanovleniyu Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 30 yanvarya 2025 goda po delu Cannavacciuolo and Others v. Italy (zhaloby Nº51567/14, 39742/14, 74208/14, 21215/15) [Right to life: the eco-test finally passed: A commentary on the Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of January 30, 2025 in the case of Cannavacciuolo and Others v. Italy (applications nos.51567/14, 39742/14, 74208/14, 21215/15)]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.15, no.1, pp.56–69. (In Russian).
References
Burki T. (2025) ECHR Condemns Italy’s Response to Toxic Waste Crisis. The Lancet Oncology, vol.26, no.3, p.284.
Galperin M. (2024) O “zelyonom” perekhode i protsessual'noy revolyutsii: Obzor postanovleniy Bol'shoy Palaty Evropeyskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka ot 9 aprelya 2024 goda po delam Karem protiv Frantsii (zhaloba Nº7189/21), Duarte Agustino i drugie protiv Portugalii i 32 drugikh (zhaloba Nº39371/20), Vereyn Klimasen'orinen Shvayts i drugie protiv Shveytsarii (zhaloba Nº53600/20) [On the “green” transition and the procedural revolution: an overview of the decisions of the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights of April 9, 2024 in Carême v. France (application no.7189/21), Duarte Agostinho and Others v. Portugal and Others and 32 Others (application no.39371/20), Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland (application no.53600/20)]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.14, no.2, pp.3–19. (In Russian).
Hamann K. (2025) Cannavacciuolo and Others v Italy: Towards Applying a Precautionary Approach to the Right to Life. EJIL: Talk! Blog of the European Journal of International Law, 5 March. Available at: https://www.ejiltalk.org/cannavacciuolo-and-others-v-italy-towards-applying-a-precautionary-approach-to-the-right-to-life (accessed: 14.03.2025).
Keller H., Heri C., Piskóty R. (2022) Something Ventured, Nothing Gained? — Remedies before the ECtHR and Their Potential for Climate Change Cases. Human Rights Law Review, vol.22, no.1. Available at: https://academic.oup.com/hrlr/article/22/1/ngab030/6497578 (accessed: 14.03.2025).
Keburiya K. (2024) V zashchitu prav cheloveka i okruzhayushchey sredy: Postanovlenie Afrikanskogo suda po pravam cheloveka i narodov ot 5 sentyabrya 2023 goda po delu Ivuariyskaya liga po pravam cheloveka i drugie protiv Kot-d’Ivuara [Protecting human rights and the environment: The Judgment of the African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights of 5 September 2023 in the case of Ivorian League for Human Rights and Others v. Côte d’Ivoire]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.14, no.4, pp.17–37. (In Russian).
Saviano R. (2024) Gomorra [Gomorrah], Moscow: Rodina. (In Russian).
Senior K., Mazza A. (2004) Italian “Triangle of Death” Linked to Waste Crisis. The Lancet Oncology, vol.5, no.9, pp.525–527.
Solntsev A. (2024) Mezhdunarodnyy tribunal po morskomu pravu v poiskakh konsensusa: Konsul'tativnoe zaklyuchenie ot 21 maya 2024 goda ob izmenenii klimata [International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in search of consensus: Advisory opinion of 21 May 2024 on climate change]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.14, no.4, pp.38–49. (In Russian).
Solntsev A., Otrashevskaya A. (2022) Razvitie kontseptsii ekologicheskikh prav cheloveka v praktike Mezhamerikanskogo suda po pravam cheloveka [Development of the concept of environmental human rights in the practice of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.12, no.1, pp.57–78. (In Russian).
Solntsev A.M. (2021) Zashchita ekologicheskikh prav cheloveka: uchebnoe posobie [Protection of environmental human rights: textbook], 3rd ed., Moscow: Rossiyskiy universitet druzhby narodov. (In Russian).
Sommardal J. (2025) A Landmark Judgment: Three Crucial Aspects of Cannavacciuolo and Others v. Italy. ECHR Blog, 4 February. Available at: https://www.echrblog.com/2025/02/by-dr.html (accessed: 14.03.2025).
Zirulia S. (2025) A New Step in the Greening of the Right to Life: The ECtHR Judgment on the Land of Fires. Verfassungsblog, 20 February. Available at: https://verfassungsblog.de/right-to-life-echr-pollution/ (accessed: 14.03.2025).