Available in Russian
Author: Tigran Oganesian
DOI: 10.21128/2226-2059-2025-2-62-79
Keywords: right to truth; right to know; evolutive interpretation; historical memory; historical truth; effective investigation
The concept of the “right to truth” allows the families of victims of gross or massive human rights violations to learn the truth about what happened to their relatives. The article analyzes the right to truth through the prism of international legal norms and key cases of the ECtHR and the IACHR, which had a significant impact on the formation of this right. When studying the vectors of evolution of the right in question, it is noted that the right to the truth has gradually expanded not only the external aspects of its application, but also its constituent elements: the right to know, the right to compensation, guarantees of non-repetition, and the obligation to conduct an effective investigation. The problem of access to archives is emphasized: it is advisable to store archival materials with a third party when there is a threat of destruction of materials or lack of proper storage conditions. The author notes the difference between the “right to know” and the “right to truth”: the conceptual idea of the “right to know” is to provide information about what happened, and the broader idea of the “right to truth” is no longer just to identify or disclose information about gross human rights violations, but to conduct an investigation to prevent the recurrence of such violations in the future. Despite the contribution of international bodies and courts, the right to truth has not yet taken on an independent form and its future looks uncertain. The analysis of the practices of the IACHR and the ECtHR highlights a fragmented approach to the issue of not only the limits of the realization of the right to the truth, but also the nature of this right. This problem is expressed in the fact that the courts are undecided and always connect the right to truth with one or another convention law in different ways. Emphasizing the evolutionary origin of the right to truth, it is noted that the subsequent fate of the right to truth will largely depend on the judges of the ECtHR and the IACHR.
Citation:
Oganesian T. (2025) Pravo na pravdu: put' k mezhdunarodnomu priznaniyu [Right to truth: the path to international recognition]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.15, no.2, pp.62–79. (In Russian).
References
Ciorciari J.D., Franzblau J.M. (2014) Hidden Files: Archival Sharing, Accountability, and the Right to the Truth. Columbia Human Rights Law Review, vol.46, no.1. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2446205 (accessed: 17.04.2025).
Dykmann K. (2007) Impunity and the Right to Truth in the Inter-American System of Human Rights. Iberoamericana, vol.7, no.26, pp.45–66.
Evseev A. (2022) Pravo na pravdu — novoe pravo cheloveka? [Right to truth — the new human right?]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.12, no.2, pp.24–37. (In Russian).
Fedorova M.M. (2019) Ponyatie dolga pamyati v kontekste sovremennykh ideologicheskikh diskursov [The concept of the duty of memory in the context of modern ideological discourses]. Kaspiyskiy region: politika, ekonomika, kul'tura, no.2, pp.133–140. (In Russian).
Gadzhiev Kh.I. (2018) O “novykh pravakh” i ikh implementatsii v natsional'nom prave (o prave na pravdu v evolyutivnom tolkovanii Evropeyskoy konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod) [On the “new rights” and their implementation in national law (on the right to truth in the evolutionary interpretation of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms)]. In: Tikhomirov Yu.A., Kovler A.I., Khavanova I.A., Sakaeva O.I. (eds.) Natsional'noe i universal'noe v prave: ot traditsiy k postmodernizmu [The national and the universal in law: from traditions to postmodernism], Moscow: Institut zakonodatel'stva i sravnitel'nogo pravovedeniya, pp.190–196. (In Russian).
Kirs E. (2013) Dva elementa v mekhanizme pravosudiya perekhodnogo perioda: mezhdunarodnye ugolovnye sudy i komissii po ustanovleniyu istiny [Two screws of the transitional justice machinery: international criminal courts and truth commissions]. Mezhdunarodnoe pravosudie, vol.3, no.2, pp.74–87. (In Russian).
Lazutin L.A., Likhachev M.A. (eds.) (2020) Mezhdunarodnoe gumanitarnoe pravo: voyna, pamyat', spravedlivost' (yuridicheskie i istoricheskie aspekty): uchebnoe posobie dlya vuzov [International humanitarian law: war, memory, justice (legal and historical aspects): textbook for universities], Moscow: Yurayt. (In Russian).
Méndez J.E., Bariffi F.J. (2011) Truth, Right to, International Protection. In: Wolfrum R. (ed.) Max Planck Encyclopaedia of Public International Law. Available at: https://www.corteidh.or.cr/tablas/r17382.pdf (accessed: 17.04.2025).
Naftali P. (2016) Crafting a “Right to Truth” in International Law: Converging Mobilizations, Diverging Agendas? Champ Pénal, vol.XIII. Available at: https://journals.openedition.org/champpenal/9245 (accessed: 17.04.2025).
Naftali P. (2017) The “Right to Truth” in International Law: The “Last Utopia”? In: Belavusau U., Gliszczyńska-Grabias A. (eds.) Law and Memory: Towards Legal Governance of History, Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press, pp.70–88.
Naqvi Y. (2006) The Right to the Truth in International Law: Fact or Fiction? International Review of the Red Cross, vol.88, no.862, pp.245–273.
Panepinto A.M. (2017) The Right to the Truth in International Law: The Significance of Strasbourg’s Contributions. Legal Studies, vol.37, no.4, pp.739–764.
Schabas W. (2019) The Right to Truth: When Does It Begin? In: Lafontaine F., Larocque F. (eds.) Doing Peace the Rights Way: Essays in International Law and Relations in Honour of Louise Arbour, Cambridge: Intersentia, pp.37–52.
Van Noorloos M. (2021) A Critical Reflection on the Right to the Truth about Gross Human Rights Violations. Human Rights Law Review, vol.21, no.4, pp.874–898.
Vasiliev A.A., Uzhanov A.E., Pechatnova Yu.V. (2023) Memorial'noe pravo: natsional'nye i mezhdunarodnye aspekty [Memorial law: national and international aspects]. Pravo i upravlenie. XXI vek, no.4, pp.63–84. (In Russian).